Clan Carmichael History and Origin

The story of the Carmichael name is woven deep into the fabric of Scottish history. Nestled in South Lanarkshire, the Carmichaels arose as loyal vassals of the powerful House of Douglas to become celebrated border wardens, valiant knights on France's battlefields, and influential diplomats.

Whether you are a genealogist tracing your roots or a history enthusiast, this guide explores the rich legacy of Clan Carmichael—from its origins near an ancient hill fort to its modern restoration.

The Origin & Name Meaning

Unlike many patronymic Scottish names, Carmichael is territorial, originating from a district in South Lanarkshire. Linguistically, it stems from the Cumbric or Brythonic elements "Caer" (fort) and "Michael" (the Archangel), translating literally as "Michael's Fort".

Local geography and church history explain the name's preservation. Tinto Hill (2,320 feet) features three ancient hill forts, referred to as a caer. Around 1058 or 1068, Queen Margaret established one of her first churches on one of these sites. Dedicated to the Archangel Michael, it was recorded in 1116 as Llan Mychel (using Cumbric llan for church). As the Scots language grew, this became "Kirk," and the surrounding parish became known as Caermichel. By the 1200s, local inhabitants adopted it as a hereditary surname.

The early Carmichael line may have descended from indigenous Cumbric Britons or Norman knights invited to settle in southern Scotland by Kings Malcolm III and David I. A formal report compiled for the second Earl of Carmichael speculates that the chiefly line likely descended from a Norman knight who migrated from Mont St. Michel in Normandy.

Norman knight migrating from Mont St. Michel in Normandy

The earliest written administrative records of the family include:

  • Robert de Carmitely: Sometime around 1220, he resigned his claims to the patronage of the church of Cleghorn.
  • Robert de Carmichael: In 1226, he witnessed a land grant in a charter of Dryburgh Abbey, marking the first official appearance of the standardized surname.

Rise to Power & Key Alliances

The consolidation of Clan Carmichael's landholdings was directly tied to their relationship with the House of Douglas, the preeminent noble dynasty of southern Scotland.

In 1321, King Robert the Bruce granted the valley of Douglasdale—including the lands of "Kirkmychel" (Carmichael)—to his key commander, Sir James Douglas. The Carmichaels served as military vassals to the Douglases. Between 1374 and 1384, William Douglas, 1st Earl of Douglas, rewarded their service by granting a formal charter of the lands of Carmichael to Sir John de Carmichael, making them recognized feudal landowners with direct administrative control.

The Carmichaels supported the Douglases in major cross-border conflicts, including the Battle of Otterburn (1388), where the Scots defeated Henry "Hotspur" Percy. The family's local standing was formally recognized in 1414, when the Barony of Carmichael was confirmed to the chief of the clan. Spanning 14,000 acres across Carmichael, Pettinain, and Carluke, the barony gave the chiefs high-level judicial and administrative authority over a critical Lowland highway.

Battle of Otterburn (1388)

The Battle of Baugé and the French Connection

In the early 15th century, Sir John de Carmichael of Meadowflat served in the Scottish force sent to aid France during the Hundred Years' War. On March 22, 1421, at the Battle of Baugé, Sir John engaged the English commander, Thomas, Duke of Clarence (brother to King Henry V), in single combat. Spurring his horse forward, Sir John unhorsed the Duke, breaking his own spear in the action. The English commander was killed, and his troops routed, winning the battle for the French-Scottish alliance. For this exploit, Sir John was rewarded by the French, later serving as Bishop of Orléans in 1426. This feat earned the Carmichaels their iconic crest of an arm holding a broken spear.

Feuds and the Darker History

The history of Clan Carmichael is deeply intertwined with the lawlessness, blood feuds, and political intrigues of the Borders.

Royal Liaisons and Religious Radicalism

In the 16th century, the family played contrasting roles in the Scottish Reformation. Catherine Carmichael, daughter of the captain of Crawford Castle, was the mistress of King James V; their son, James Stewart, was later legitimized and became a half-brother to Mary, Queen of Scots. Conversely, Peter Carmichael of Balmedie embraced radical Protestantism and was implicated in the 1546 assassination of Cardinal David Beaton at St Andrews Castle. Sentenced to the French galleys alongside reformer John Knox, Peter later escaped and actively fought for the Protestant cause.

Sir John Carmichael and the "Border Badlands"

During the turbulent era of the Border reivers, Sir John Carmichael served as Chief from 1585 to 1599 and Warden of the West Marches. Regarded as "the most expert borderer" in Scotland, he strictly enforced march law, famously leading Scottish forces to victory at the Battle of the Redeswire in 1575. His strictness ultimately cost him his life; in June 1600, Sir John was ambushed and shot in the back by a party of Armstrong clansmen. King James VI was so outraged that he systematically pursued and hanged the conspirators between 1601 and 1605.

A Tragic Brother-Against-Brother Civil War

During the 1640s civil war, family loyalties fractured along generational lines. James Carmichael, the 1st Lord Carmichael, supported King Charles I, but his sons were divided: Sir Daniel commanded the Covenanter Clydesdale Regiment for Parliament, while John and James fought as Royalist cavalry officers. At the Battle of Marston Moor in 1644, Captain John was tragically killed while fighting directly against the Parliamentarian Clydesdale Regiment, which was commanded by his own brother, Sir Daniel.

Clan Castles & Territories

Clan Carmichael's territorial footprints are marked by defensive towers and baronial mansions.

Carmichael Castle and Carmichael House

The original Carmichael Castle was constructed around 1414 as a fortified tower house by William, 2nd Baron of Carmichael. Oliver Cromwell’s forces systematically destroyed the castle in 1650 to punish the 1st Lord Carmichael for his support of Charles I. In its place, Carmichael House was begun in 1734 under the direction of John Carmichael, 3rd Earl of Hyndford. Today, the site stands as roofless ruins, consolidated and restored between 1996 and 2000.

Eastend House

Located 2 km from the main estate, Eastend House was acquired by a branch of the family around 1500. This structure features a 16th-century L-plan tower keep integrated with later classical and Scots Baronial additions. It escaped Cromwell's campaign undamaged, suggesting that the Eastend branch remained loyal to the Covenanter government. In 1851, they commissioned a large Scots Baronial wing and a round entrance tower by architect David Bryce. Today, the house is vacant and deteriorating.

Fenton Tower

Located in East Lothian, Fenton Tower was originally built around 1550 by Patrick Whytelaw. In 1587, ownership was forfeited to Sir John Carmichael and his wife Margaret Douglas. Sacked by Cromwell's forces in 1650, the tower was restored as a luxury hotel in 1998.

Mauldslie Castle

Located in the Clyde Valley, Mauldslie Castle was built in 1792–1793 by Robert Adam for Thomas Carmichael, 5th Earl of Hyndford. Although the main castle was demolished in 1935, its Category A listed structures survive, including the Gothic Revival Mauldslie Castle West Lodge completed in 1861 by David Bryce.

Castle Craig (Peeblesshire)

Castle Craig is a restrained classical mansion with flanked pavilions, commissioned in 1798 by Sir John Gibson-Carmichael. Since 1988, Castle Craig has operated as a world-renowned addiction rehabilitation clinic.

Symbols & Identifiers

The visual heraldry and traditions of Clan Carmichael serve as a proud connection to their historical achievements:

  • The Clan Motto: The official motto of Clan Carmichael is "Tout Jour Prest" (Medieval French for "Always Ready").
  • The Plant Badge: Under Scottish tradition, clansmen wore specific foliage in their bonnets to identify their allegiance:
    • The Rue: Because the Carmichaels are historically recognized as a principal sept and ally of Clan Douglas, they adopted the Douglas plant badge, the hardy and resilient rue.
    • The Oak: The oak is also recorded as the clan plant, derived from the white horses on the Chief's coat of arms, collared with oak branches.
  • The Clan Crest: The crest badge features "a dexter hand and arm in pale armed and holding a broken spear Proper", commemorating Sir John de Carmichael's single combat at the Battle of Baugé in 1421.
  • The Clan Tartan: The official Carmichael tartan features a green base intersected by broader blue bands, flanked by narrower black, red, and yellow lines (defined by the thread count K/6 G72 B56 R4 B4 Y/6). First recorded in 1905, the tartan was officially confirmed and registered with the Court of the Lord Lyon by Chief Richard Carmichael in 1981.

Clan Carmichael Crest digital download: Includes Color PNG, B&W PNG, and SVG vector files

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Carmichael a Highland or Lowland clan?

Clan Carmichael is historically a Lowland Scottish clan originating from South Lanarkshire. However, a distinct Western Highland branch arose in Argyll (on Lismore and in Appin) from Galloway MacMichaels who became recognized septs of the Highland clans MacDougall and Stewart of Appin.

What is the Carmichael war cry?

The official war cry and motto of the clan is "Tout Jour Prest" (Medieval French for "Always Ready"), which was shouted by clansmen in battle to signify their constant state of military preparedness.

Who is the current Chief of Clan Carmichael?

The current hereditary chief of the clan is Andrew Carmichael of Carmichael, who succeeded his father, Chief Richard Carmichael, as the 31st Chief of the Name and Arms and the 27th Baron of Carmichael in 2025.

References

Back to blog